Crisp gives you live chat, a visual chatbot builder and MagicReply, the AI feature that suggests replies to your agents based on past conversations. For most growing businesses, that combination works well until it does not. The limitation is structural: Crisp’s AI is designed to assist human agents, not to resolve customer questions autonomously when no one is at the keyboard.
This review covers seven options for Crisp users who need more from AI: what Crisp’s built-in AI actually does, which tools go further, and how to decide whether to extend Crisp or replace it.
What Crisp’s built-in AI does, and where it stops
Crisp currently offers two AI-driven features:
- MagicReply reads the incoming customer message and suggests a reply to the agent based on past conversations and knowledge-base content. The agent reviews the suggestion and sends or edits it.
- Conversation summaries condense long threads so a new agent picking up a case does not have to scroll through the full history.
Both features make agents faster. Neither replaces the agent. A customer who messages at 11pm on a Saturday does not get MagicReply; they get an offline message and a wait.
The gap this creates matters most in three situations:
- Ecommerce stores with repetitive, data-dependent questions. “Is this in stock in size M?” and “Where is my order?” require a lookup against your product or fulfilment data. MagicReply cannot perform that lookup; a purpose-built ecommerce AI can.
- Teams operating across time zones or without evening cover. Agent-assistance AI does not help if there is no agent to assist.
- Businesses scaling support without scaling headcount. If the goal is to handle more enquiries with the same team, autonomous AI resolution is the mechanism, not faster agent responses.
Three questions to answer before choosing a tool
- Do you need autonomous resolution or faster agent responses? Autonomous AI resolves questions without a human. Agent-assistance AI speeds up agents who are already online. Most tools offer one or the other; some offer both.
- What are the questions your customers actually ask? AI that pulls from your product catalogue, policies and order system resolves ecommerce questions. General-purpose AI built on conversation history resolves general questions. Match the AI type to the question type.
- Are you extending Crisp or replacing it? Some tools integrate with Crisp via webhook or Zapier and add AI on top. Others replace the whole stack. Understand what you are actually buying.
The 7 best AI chatbots for Crisp users
| Tool | Best for | AI type | Channels | Starting price | Trial |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AeroChat | Shopify ecommerce | Autonomous AI | Shopify, WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook, email | $49/month | 7-day trial |
| Tidio (Lyro) | SMB ecommerce | Autonomous AI | Web, email, Instagram, Messenger | Free; from $24/month | Free plan |
| Gorgias | High-volume Shopify | AI resolution add-on | Email, live chat, social | $10/month | None listed |
| Intercom | SaaS and product-led | Autonomous AI (Fin) | Web, email, mobile | From $29/seat/month | 14 days |
| Freshchat | Mid-market businesses | AI agent (Freddy) | Web, email, WhatsApp, social | Free; from $15/month | Free plan |
| Zendesk Chat | Enterprise teams | AI agent (Zendesk AI) | Web, email, social, phone | From $55/agent/month | 14 days |
| Crisp (built-in AI) | SMBs on current stack | Agent-assistance AI | Web, email, WhatsApp, social | Free; from EUR25/month | Free plan |
1. AeroChat
Best for: Shopify ecommerce stores that want autonomous AI across multiple channels.
AeroChat connects directly to your Shopify product catalogue, inventory, store policies and FAQs, then uses that data to resolve customer questions without agent involvement. A customer who asks about sizing, stock availability, return policies, order status or product comparisons gets an accurate answer from the AI, not a wait-for-an-agent message.
The channel coverage is relevant for merchants who have outgrown Crisp’s scope. AeroChat handles web chat, WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook and email from one workspace. Growth-plan users get WhatsApp broadcast campaigns alongside inbound support; Advanced adds auto-translation so the AI responds in the customer’s own language.
Where Crisp offers MagicReply as an agent aid, AeroChat operates the first layer of response end-to-end. Human handover is available when the AI cannot resolve the enquiry, but the majority of standard ecommerce questions should not reach that point.
Plans start at $49/month (Starter: 500 AI responses) with a 7-day trial on all plans. That trial gives you enough time to connect your data, run a realistic set of test questions and measure how much of your weekly support volume the AI can handle before committing to a plan.
What it does not cover: AeroChat is built for Shopify. If your store runs on WooCommerce or another platform, check compatibility before trialling.
2. Tidio (Lyro AI)
Best for: SMB ecommerce on WooCommerce or Shopify wanting autonomous AI at a lower entry price.
Tidio’s Lyro AI is an autonomous conversational AI trained on your knowledge base and FAQ content. Unlike Crisp’s MagicReply, which assists agents, Lyro handles the full customer interaction when an agent is not available.
Tidio’s billing structure is more complex than it appears: the Starter plan at $24.17/month (annual) includes 100 human support conversations and 50 Lyro AI conversations as a one-off starting credit. The AI conversation allowance and the human support conversation allowance are two separate meters. Get accurate estimates from your own support data before projecting costs.
The free plan gives you a starting point, but 50 Lyro AI conversations is a limited test window for stores with meaningful support volume.
3. Gorgias
Best for: Shopify stores with established support teams and high ticket volume.
Gorgias is a helpdesk platform built around the Shopify ecosystem. It pulls customer and order data directly from Shopify so agents can see purchase history, order status and conversation history in one panel. The Gorgias AI Agent resolves common questions autonomously; the helpdesk base handles everything that needs a person.
The pricing structure has two layers: the helpdesk subscription (from $10/month for 50 tickets) plus AI Agent usage at approximately $0.90 per fully resolved conversation. This model suits a team that already relies on a structured helpdesk and wants to layer AI resolution on top, not a store looking for a first chatbot.
For detailed pricing comparisons across Gorgias and other Shopify chatbots, the pricing breakdown covers all cost components.
4. Intercom (Fin AI)
Best for: SaaS companies and product-led businesses with complex user enquiries.
Intercom’s Fin is a well-regarded autonomous AI that resolves customer questions by drawing from your knowledge base, articles and conversation data. It escalates to a human when the AI cannot confidently answer. Intercom also has robust lifecycle messaging: onboarding sequences, behaviour-triggered messages and user segmentation built into the same platform as the support inbox.
For ecommerce specifically, Intercom is a more general-purpose tool than one built around a product catalogue. The pricing reflects the breadth of the platform: seat-based pricing with usage components can reach meaningful sums for a team of five or more. It is strong for businesses where customer engagement spans the whole product lifecycle rather than individual purchase transactions.
5. Freshchat
Best for: Mid-market businesses needing AI across web, mobile and WhatsApp in one platform.
Freshchat is part of the Freshworks suite and includes Freddy AI, an autonomous agent that handles common queries and escalates to a human inbox when needed. The platform covers web chat, email, WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger and mobile push in one interface, which suits businesses that need broad channel reach without managing separate tools.
Freshchat’s strength is the Freshworks ecosystem: if your business already uses Freshdesk (support), Freshsales (CRM) or Freshservice (IT), Freshchat shares data across those systems. The free plan covers up to ten agents with basic AI functionality; paid plans begin at $15 per agent per month.
6. Zendesk Chat
Best for: Enterprise teams with structured support operations and compliance requirements.
Zendesk’s AI agent handles customer questions across web chat, email, social and voice. The platform’s strength is its depth of reporting, workflow automation and integration ecosystem. For a team of 50+ agents, Zendesk’s ability to route tickets, track SLA performance and generate custom reports matters more than price.
For smaller ecommerce stores, Zendesk’s per-agent pricing and configuration complexity are typically disproportionate to the support volume. Zendesk Suite starts at $55 per agent per month; the AI capabilities are on the higher tiers.
7. Crisp’s own AI (MagicReply)
Best for: Businesses already on Crisp who need faster agents, not autonomous resolution.
If your customer service operation primarily runs during business hours and your support team is already active on Crisp, MagicReply accelerates what they do without any migration. The Starter plan at $95/month gives unlimited agents with knowledge base integration and the MagicReply AI feature.
The case for staying on Crisp’s own AI is strongest when: your enquiries are too varied or nuanced for autonomous AI to handle reliably, your team is online during your customers’ peak hours, and extending your current stack is lower-risk than migrating to a new platform.
Autonomous AI vs agent-assistance AI: which your store needs
Migrating from Crisp: what to do with conversation history
Switching support platforms means deciding what to do with existing data. Crisp allows you to export conversations as a JSON file from the Settings > Exports panel. The steps before cancelling your Crisp account:
- Export all conversations and contacts from Crisp’s Settings > Exports section.
- Check whether your new platform can import Crisp data directly. Most do not have a native Crisp importer, which means conversations stay in Crisp’s export files for reference rather than migrating into the new system.
- Keep a read-only Crisp plan active during the transition period if agents need to reference historical conversations. The Free plan gives two agent seats and read access to the inbox.
- Run your new platform in parallel for at least two weeks before removing Crisp from your website. Route new conversations to the new tool while keeping historical context accessible in Crisp.
- Update your knowledge base in the new platform before going live. The AI’s output quality is directly proportional to the accuracy and coverage of its source material.
Which tool fits your situation
| Situation | Recommended first look | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Shopify store, repetitive product and order questions | AeroChat | Pulls from your Shopify product and order data; autonomous resolution |
| WooCommerce or multi-platform ecommerce store | Tidio (Lyro) | Works across platforms; lower entry price; autonomous Lyro AI |
| Shopify store with 5+ support agents and high ticket volume | Gorgias | Shopify-native helpdesk with AI resolution layer; strong team workflow tools |
| SaaS product with complex, context-dependent support | Intercom (Fin) | Lifecycle messaging plus AI resolution; strong for product-led businesses |
| Business needing WhatsApp AI at scale across markets | Freshchat | Freddy AI covers WhatsApp natively; integrates with Freshworks CRM and helpdesk |
| Enterprise team, multiple brands, compliance requirements | Zendesk | Deep reporting, SLA management, and enterprise security controls |
| SMB staying on Crisp, agents available during business hours | Crisp MagicReply | No migration needed; MagicReply accelerates existing agents during covered hours |
Questions to ask before switching
- How many of your current support conversations happen outside business hours? If more than 20% of messages arrive when your team is offline, agent-assistance AI is not solving the core problem.
- What data does the AI need to answer your most common questions? Map your top 20 question types to data sources (product catalogue, policies, order system, FAQs) and check whether each candidate tool can access those sources.
- How will you measure resolution quality after switching? Define what a good AI response looks like for your specific questions before the trial. CSAT scores and resolution rate are the two numbers to track from day one.
- What does the handover to a human look like? Test the edge cases: a complaint, a complex return, a question the AI cannot answer. The handover experience is what the customer remembers when the AI does not resolve the issue.
- What is the total migration cost? Include the new platform’s monthly fee, the time cost of setting up knowledge bases and integrations, training agents on the new interface, and any overlap period where you run both platforms simultaneously.
If you are using Crisp today and your main question is whether autonomous AI would change your support economics, the clearest test is running a purpose-built AI against a week’s worth of your real enquiries. AeroChat’s 7-day trial lets you connect your Shopify data and test exactly that without a credit card commitment. The Shopify AI chatbot comparison covers what each of the major tools does beyond just resolving questions.
